AI Pricing: Separating Fact From Fear [Cowboy State Daily Show]

How dynamic pricing, digital shelf tags and surveillance pricing work, and what shoppers and brands should know about each.

Episode Overview

Most shoppers hear "AI pricing" and picture a store charging them more than the person standing next to them. On the Cowboy State Daily Show with host Jake Nichols, Mike Danford, Chief Strategy Officer at Adverio, explains why the picture is mostly about incentives.

Mike sorts AI pricing into three different things. Dynamic pricing moves with supply and demand, the same way gas prices shift by the hour. Digital shelf tags let a store change thousands of prices in minutes instead of paying staff to swap paper tags for two days. Surveillance pricing, where your own data sets your price, is the controversial one.

Core insight: Retailers want to show you the price you are most likely to buy at. Pricing individual shoppers inside a physical store brings regulators and lost loyalty, so for most retailers it isn't worth the squeeze.

The conversation covers why the tests that made headlines, like Target in 2022, backfired, and how the same data often works in the shopper's favor through abandoned cart coupons, exit offers and loyalty pricing. Mike also shares the simplest way to protect your data: read what you approve, and think twice before logging into apps with your Google or Amazon account.

The last part of the episode turns to search. Mike explains that every product now has three kinds of shoppers: people, a platform's built-in AI assistant and outside AI tools, plus voice search through devices like Alexa. Each one reads a listing differently, and all of them depend on clean, structured product data. This is the same work behind Amazon account management and getting products named when shoppers ask AI what to buy.

If you want to separate fact from fear on AI pricing, this conversation gives you a clear map of what is happening today and what is still far off.

What You'll Learn in This Episode

  • The three types of AI pricing: dynamic pricing, digital shelf tags and surveillance pricing
  • Who holds your shopping data and the simplest ways to protect it
  • Why retailers use your data to grow the cart with bundles and add-ons
  • Why the Target pricing test in 2022 wasn't worth it for the retailer
  • How abandoned cart coupons, exit offers and loyalty pricing can work in your favor
  • How digital shelf tags cut labor and keep prices consistent across thousands of SKUs
  • Why the app price and the shelf price at the same store must match
  • Whether two shoppers could pay different prices for the same item in one store
  • The three kinds of shoppers every product now has to win: people, platform AI and outside AI tools
  • Why clean product data and SEO still matter as AI and voice search grow

Highlights

  • 25:27 Welcome
  • 26:50 Is this where pricing is headed?
  • 27:23 Three types of AI pricing
  • 28:18 Who holds your shopping data
  • 30:19 Why retailers bundle and grow the cart
  • 31:37 Why the Target test wasn't worth it
  • 32:51 Coupons, loyalty and abandoned cart offers
  • 36:08 How digital shelf tags work
  • 37:27 The Target parking lot problem
  • 38:21 Could two shoppers pay different prices in one store?
  • 40:09 SEO, AI assistants and voice search
  • 42:31 Outro

Episode Transcript

Jake: And we're back on a Finally Friday edition of the Cowboy State Daily Show, joined by Mike Danford, our first guest today. Mike, I was just talking about a story that China is using artificial intelligence to burn the wings off of mosquitoes with a laser, and I'm like, "Yeah, finally AI has a useful use."

Mike: Love it.

Jake: Yeah, Mike is using AI for all different things, but he's owner and chief revenue officer of Adverio. Is that how I say it? Adverio?

Mike: That's correct, yeah.

Jake: A marketplace growth agency founded all the way back in 2014, when AI was just an infant. The company manages more than 350,000 SKUs, works with Walmart and other major retailers. Our topic today is retailers increasingly using artificial intelligence to price items. We're going to dive deep into digital price tags. And when you have a price tag that's not fixed, if I can't see the price on the loaf of bread because it's just digital, it immediately conjures worries. Am I paying what my neighbor is paying? Am I paying the same at 9:00 in the morning as I will at 9:00 at night? We see similar things at the gas station, depending on what hour you go to buy gas. Very interesting. Is this the trend, Mike? Is this where we're headed?

Mike: Yeah, absolutely. And there's three different ways of looking at it. This type of pricing has been around, like you mentioned with the gas stations, etc. At a high level you have dynamic pricing, which is what you're talking about, different times of the day, different days of the week, and that's based on supply and demand, that's what it's mostly driven by. Then you have the digital shelf tags, which we'll dig into. And the other side of that is surveillance pricing, which is pricing based on the consumer, the shopper, which is the more controversial take, if you will.

Jake: Yeah. Well, it's all got interesting aspects to talk about. Let's talk about dynamic pricing, pricing that can change. That would be difficult to do in the old days, but today with digital pricing, during a snowstorm in Minnesota, you could be paying more for a shovel. That could happen, yeah?

Mike: Oh, yeah, surge pricing is a thing, for sure.

Jake: Now, some of this stuff is useful if the data collected is helping us as consumers, helping us as shoppers. We've seen that online, where Amazon, Facebook, all the social, everything I do online, it all feeds a database that understands me better and in some ways is very helpful. It probably knows what I'm interested in buying and knows what I have no interest in.

Mike: Absolutely. And the more data you give it, the bigger the picture it can have, and so you get different pricing or different incentives depending on the platforms and your history, for sure.

Jake: Yeah, and whenever it's the cloud or some database, somebody owns the database, somebody is collecting. It may be an outfit like yours or maybe the retailer itself. But that makes people worried that their stuff is being held somewhere. Is that a concern? Who has access to information about you as a consumer?

Mike: Yeah, so typically the marketplace or the platform, whatever you're using, is going to have that data and they're going to protect it, and in most instances you've checked a box somewhere along the way that says, "Hey, you can use my data." So the biggest thing, if you're concerned with this, is to read what you're checking and read what you're approving. Every time you log in with Google or Amazon, every time you connect an app, all the information transfers and shares over. So that's your biggest way to protect yourself, for sure.

Jake: Well, it's certainly a growing trend now, but it's been around for a little bit, as you pointed out, Mike. Let's talk about, for instance, if I'm on Kayak or Expedia, if I'm traveling, as soon as I'm looking into buying tickets for a flight to Houston, next thing you know, there's hotel lodging in Houston. Oh, you might need a rental car. They've been doing that a long time.

Mike: Yeah, absolutely. It's all about what they call increasing the bundle or increasing the cart. Hey, you've already raised your hand that you're going to some destination or you're going to purchase this thing, and here are supplementary or complementary products. It's just like going in a grocery store, where it's designed for you to go through, and you're going to go to cold milk, dairy, frozen or whatever, and you go across that process. And at the very end when you check out, you have the impulse cart, right? It's all part of it. It's just trying to make it digital and get the most out of you while you're there.

Jake: Yeah, and I don't know how you even program for that. This is the computers making these decisions, but they're never wrong, right? It doesn't take long. You do two or three things and pretty soon the computer develops an algorithm. It's like, I know you.

Mike: Yep. A lot of times I would say it's a lot less unique to the person or where they're at specifically. It's more about trends over time and data mining that and understanding it. A lot of the tests that are going on, where Target got hit in 2022 and then you have McDonald's going through some stuff right now, it's not worth the squeeze for the retailers. A consumer may feel like they're going to be priced more, but about half the time it's reducing the price based on whatever information it has. So it's advantageous almost as often as it's not. And with Amazon, outside the dynamic piece, they want to be the lowest price, kind of like the Walmart incentive, rollback low prices, etc. If you have a product on Amazon, you're not really able to sell it on Amazon if your price is lower somewhere else. So they're controlling the price from their platform as well. So there is incentive, and these retailers want you to buy products, so they want to put the price that you're most likely to purchase at that time. That's the incentive.

Jake: And let's face it, there's all kinds of data about you out there even if you haven't checked the box and agreed. There's just things that computers are going to know about you. AI is going to know about you. Mike, let's talk about when it's advantageous for you, when it might not be, when there might be price gouging. Let's say you're looking into a purchase and a website knows your zip code is 27514. Automatically, you're going to get a markup for that Tar Heels hoodie, and you'll probably be bombarded with BOGO offers for a Duke T-shirt. You're going to be profiled. Are you going to be price gouged or are you going to get a better price? I don't know.

Mike: I think it's mostly incentives. Again, the whole goal is to find out what you're most likely to purchase, how they can present that, and what price you're most likely to purchase at. There's no incentive for them to show you products you're not going to purchase. They want to understand as much as possible, and they want to give you the best offer based on that. Where it gets advantageous is that some products take longer. There's a longer purchase journey or buyer journey. A $10 item is kind of disposable, you may just purchase the one that pops up. Something that's $500 or $1,000, you may think about it a little while. You might want to go around and price shop and look at other websites. So it'll track that. It'll say, "Hey, you looked at these products. You put this product in your cart. You thought about it." So the next time you visit, a day or so later or maybe next week, you might have a coupon presented: "Hey, I saw you were in the cart. Here's 10%," trying to get you across that line. That's where the advantage is. And I'm sure you've seen it, where you go on a website, you click the X button, and it says, "But wait, here's a coupon before you leave," or here's an incentive to sign up. The other part is loyalty. Are you a frequent buyer? Are you a frequent shopper? What are you looking at across our products and catalogs? Here are some other products within our brand that you might want based on that. So what are your affinities? If you go on one of these marketplaces or platforms, or even airfare, there's thousands and thousands of options. If your affinity is premium hotels, or you like first class over another cabin, or you like premium or quality products, then as it learns that, it's going to do a better job of curating and presenting those products for you. So I think those are all the advantages, for sure.

Jake: Very interesting. Just reading this Associated Press story about dynamic pricing and surveillance pricing, I encountered two pop-ups landing on the website. I thought we got rid of pop-ups. They're back with a vengeance. I had another pop-up while I was scrolling, a video playing in the lower right-hand corner, and as soon as I tried to exit the page, "Don't leave yet." Golly, I'm bombarded. Anyway, that's an aside. It's not your fault, Mike. Mike Danford is with us. We're talking about AI. Let's talk about how your company is seeing major retailers harnessing AI. I'm thinking of the Piggly Wiggly trying to understand why crunchy peanut butter is not selling and creamy is. Previously you had to do a year-end inventory or check stuff once a month. Now you have real-time information and intel, and you can use that to market, to decide when something goes on sale. It has to be a huge, powerful tool for retailers.

Mike: I used to work in a couple of groceries here in the Carolinas when I was in high school and college. One was a more premium experience than the others. There was a person who would come every Tuesday when the promotional circulars came out and the prices changed, and it would take them one to two days to go through the hundreds of tags. You've got to pull last week's price tags, put the new ones on, and replace the prices. This is over a day or two, and it's confusing for the people in the store because they'll see two different prices or stickers. It's a whole thing. So that's where I like it, and being in Europe, I've seen the digital tags over there as well. It's a more common theme over there. This allows them to update and deploy price changes on that weekly circular within a few minutes, as opposed to having someone take a couple of days. Then you scale this. A typical grocer is going to have 7,000 products or SKUs. You go to a Walmart or a larger retailer, they're going to have 120,000 items. That's 17 times the products you have to change. Digital tags allow them to do that at scale. So it helps them with labor costs, helps them with consistency, etc. Where the issues have happened in the past is, I'm looking at my app in the parking lot. This was the Target issue specifically. I go into the store and the store tag is different from what my app says, at the same exact store. So I'm online looking, or I'm in the store, and there's two different prices. That's the issue. That's what everything's being cracked down on. That's what's not allowed.

Jake: Yeah, and I imagine we'll see litigation crafted. Each state will probably come up with some way to rein some of this in, because here's where we're headed. I'm thinking, Mike, of a worst case scenario. Like those Expedia commercials, two people are sitting on an airplane and one says, "I got this seat for $372," and the other one says, "I paid 800 for this flight." It all has to do with dynamic pricing, surveillance pricing. Now here's where it can get hinky, Mike. You go to a store, Target or whatever, and you buy one of those Swiffer replacement pads. Well, if you recently purchased a Swiffer, AI knows you're probably going to need those pads and maybe prices you more. With live digital pricing, I walk up, and I haven't ever bought a Swiffer. There's no data collected on me about a Swiffer, and I go to buy the pad and it's pretty cheap. Meanwhile, AI knows the other guy: oh, I got him, he can't use a Swiffer without the pads. He's paying something different. We're both grabbing the same item at the same time at the same store. Could that happen?

Mike: I think that's what all this litigation is cracking down on. There have been ways of trying it. So far, what the retailers are stating is that it's cohort based. They don't have the unique details about you, but certain times of the day, certain places, etc., they'll have pricing there. But a physical store having multiple prices for the same product depending on who's coming through, I don't think that's going to happen anytime soon. It's kind of happening with in-store versus the app, and it's already being cracked down on for that. So I would say that's pretty far off. I think there's going to be regulatory agencies involved that won't allow it, and it's going to put a bad taste in the mouth for your brand loyalty as well. So you don't want that either. And I'm not sure I could ever see where the juice is worth the squeeze to do that. There's a lot of assumptions that have to be made there. I just can't see the benefit from it.

Jake: Hey, one last thing, Mike. Adverio, the outfit you're with, do you do things like optimize SEO? Is that even a thing anymore? People who have a small business, I'm thinking of some listeners here in Wyoming, may be trying to harness artificial intelligence, developing a social presence, building pages. You used to know certain catchphrases the search engines were looking for. Now, when you have AI trawling, machine-first indexing, has that become a thing, where you're trying to learn what AI is looking for in your pages?

Mike: Yeah, now you have three different types of shoppers. It used to be, with SEO, it was humans looking and digging through, their semantics and how they're searching, looking at images and videos and copy and reading everything. It has to be appealing, and there's some psychology to it, because we're humans and we need some persuasion. The next layer now is that inside a platform you have its own AI bot, and you're engaging with it, it's having a dialogue with you, and it's trying to promote and push you through. And the last part is maybe using an external AI tool. Anytime AI gets involved, it doesn't care how pretty an image is, and it doesn't need any sales psychology. It wants factual information. Hey, my shopper has an affinity for this. They don't like this. They only do this. Whatever the details are, that's the data you have. And when the AI looks at the product, it wants to know yes or no. Does it do this? Does it include this? Will it solve this problem? So that's what you have to be able to do for all three of them, which is what we do. And then you have another one, voice search, specifically with Amazon and some other platforms where you're talking to it. Hey Alexa, order this, add this to cart. So now you have so many different ways in, and you have to cater to all of them. Fortunately, you're covered as long as you have good, clean product data and structure, which is increasingly important because that's what the AI ties into. SEO still matters. You still have humans shopping. You still have to have the presentation. So it's just more to do, and if you have good SEO infrastructure in place, it helps the AI as well. So you still have to do it. It's not obsolete by any means.

Jake: Ever changing landscape, but Adverio's been ahead of the curve since 2014. Mike Danford is running that, he's the owner and chief revenue officer of Adverio. Read up on them and learn more. Hey, Mike, thanks for being on. Very interesting. Always fascinating, this discussion, when we're talking about AI and how businesses are using it.

Mike: Yeah, thanks so much for having me.

Jake: Have a great weekend.

See how AI shopping reads your catalog

A shopper asked AI for the best in your category and it did not name you. Run the three-layer AI Shopping Readiness check and see where you are losing the sale, ranked by impact.

Get My Products Named by AI

Takes 2 minutes. No call required.

Prefer to talk it through? Map your profit leaks with a strategist

Ready to Stop Guessing and Start Growing?

We’ll build your custom roadmap to higher profit.